Rates Performance Measurement and Benchmarking

Rates Performance Measurement and Benchmarking

July 15, 2021 | Online :: Central Time

“This course was relevant and thought provoking. Time very well spent!” – Manager, Rates and Finance, BC Hydro

“Great speakers, thorough coverage of topics, knowledgeable presenters.” – Staff Rate Analyst, PSE&G

Retail electricity services integrates largely competitive generation services with regulated delivery services, including transmission and distribution (T&D). Contemporary electricity markets reflect many entities operating under ever-widening regulatory arrangements to accommodate stakeholders participating from all corners. Yet, at the end of the day it comes down to performance for utilities: have the changes put in place over recent years obtained net benefits? What is performance and how is it gauged? This course addresses essential elements of these questions and provides plausible answers.

Utilities, intervenors, and regulators all use benchmarking to appraise the reasonableness of historical costs and forecasts of future costs. The results can be used to help set rates in rate cases and the out-year provisions of multiyear rate plans. This course will review cost benchmarking methods and key topics include:

  • The underlying structure of financial costs
  • Determining revenue requirements
  • Various cost components
  • Data and information sources
  • Example analyses

Learning Outcomes

  • Discuss the definition of performance as well as its attributes and features
  • Review how to distinguish electricity from conventional markets as non-regulated markets have significant competition
  • Discuss performance-based regulations (PBR) impact on performance
  • Review the regulatory standards at work and their impacts on the competitive market process
  • Explore performance benchmarking within cost-based regulation as an alternative approach
  • Review the measurement of cost performance by selecting comparable peer groups
  • Review the measuring of service quality performance
  • Discuss the current reliability measures



Thursday, July 15, 2021 : Central Time

8:45 – 9:00 a.m.
Log In

9:00 – 9:10 a.m.
Opening Announcements

12:30 – 1:15 p.m.
Lunch Break

9:00 a.m. – 5:00 p.m.
Course Timing

Short breaks will be taken in the morning and afternoon


  • Performance—what is it?
    • A plausible definition
      • The dimensions/attributes of products and services
    • Differences of attributes and features across product lines
      • Similarities
      • Relevance of attributes
  • Electricity services
    • Measurable quantities
    • Service package attached to the provision of electricity.
      • Multiple service attributes
      • A core function and capability necessary for macroeconomies

Distinguishing Electricity from Conventional Markets

  • Competition in non-regulated markets
    • Suppliers face potential loss of market share
    • Competition disciplines suppliers
  • Service providers face less competitive pressure
    • Regulatory authorities serve as surrogates for competitive market processes
      • Regulatory standards at work and impacts
        1. Resource adequacy criteria
        2. Measured service quality
      • Performance-based regulations (PBR) impact on performance
        • Explicit penalties for substandard performance, observed and measured
        • Is PBR the best governance structure
      • No alternative to cost-based regulation
        • Substantial economies of scale and scope
        • Firm-level knowledge
        • Models of competition
  • Electricity remains largely unchanged
    • Ongoing scale economies in power delivery (T&D) services
      • Costly to evolve and overhaul incumbency
      • Evolution to workable competition
        1. End result could underperform expectations
        2. Relevant case example: February ’21 experience in ERCOT

Alternative Approach: Performance Benchmarking Within Cost-Based Regulation

  • The performance of incumbent electricity service providers compared to that of selected peer group
    • Set prices subject to performance
    • Yardstick Competition by another name
  • Suggested performance metrics
    • Cost level
    • Total factor productivity (TFP)
    • Survey-based service quality
      • Customer call performance; responsiveness to on-site service inquiries; responsiveness to new-service requests, etc.

Measuring Cost Performance

  • Selection of comparable peer group
    • Determining the relevant characteristics that underly peer group selection
      • Pooled time series-cross sectional analysis
        • Addresses the question: just why is electric distribution services in midtown Manhattan threefold higher than Des Moines Iowa?
  • Cost measurement
    • All-in cost metrics
      • Cost elements (generation, transmission, distribution, etc.
      • Capital-related cost components
      • Fuel costs and purchased power
      • Operations and maintenance costs
      • Weighted average cost of capital
  • Output quantities including production quantities, peak loads, etc.
    • Productivity metrics
    • Output quantities
    • Input quantities including:
      • Christensen-Jorgenson based measures of capital
      • Highly differentiated cost indexes
      • Industry-specific regional labor compensation
      • Marginal cost of capital
      • Market-based fuel costs

Measuring Service Quality Performance

  • Survey-based measures of service quality
    • Analysis and filed service quality reports before regulators

Measuring Reliability

  • Current reliability measures
    • System Average Interruption Duration Index
    • IEEE standard 1366
  • Analysis and filed reliability quality reports before DOE regulators

Concluding Comments


Robert Camfield, Senior Regulatory Consultant, Christensen Associates

Robert Camfield is Senior Regulatory Consultant at Christensen Associates.  He has extensive experience in the energy industry and the economics of regulation, including resource decisions, regulatory governance and incentive plans, market restructuring, cost allocation, energy contracts, cost of capital, and performance benchmarking. Mr. Camfield has managed numerous projects involving wholesale and retail markets, including market restructuring in Central Europe.  He served as the program director for EEI’s Transmission and Wholesale Markets summer program from 1999 – 2008 and is credited with innovations related to web-based energy services, cost analysis, and two-part tariffs for transmission. Prior to joining Christensen Associates, he served as system economist for Southern Company and chief economist for New Hampshire Public Utilities Commission.

Nick Crowley, Economist, Christensen Associates

Nicholas Crowley, MS (University of Wisconsin–Madison) is an Economist at Christensen Associates.  His professional work is primarily with natural gas pipeline and electricity regulation, including wholesale and retail markets. For electricity, he has participated in numerous costing and pricing projects, which involve computational analytics and econometrics, performance-based ratemaking, marginal cost estimation, total factor productivity estimates, and load response with respect to efficient time-of-use tariff options within retail markets. Mr. Crowley’s analyses and study results have been summarized in major reports and formal studies filed with regulatory authorities in Canada and the U.S. Prior to joining CA Energy Consulting,  he served as an economist with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, where his work experience was concentrated in natural gas pipeline regulation and assessment of electricity markets. Mr. Crowley was also involved in FERC’s performance-based regulation of oil pipeline rates.

Online Delivery

We will be using Microsoft Teams to facilitate your participation in the upcoming event. You do not need to have an existing Teams account in order to participate in the broadcast – the course will play in your browser and you will have the option of using a microphone to speak with the room and ask questions, or type any questions in via the chat window and our on-site representative will relay your question to the instructor.

          • IMPORTANT NOTE: After November 30 you will not be able to join a Teams meeting using Internet Explorer 11. Microsoft recommends downloading and installing the Teams app if possible. You may also use the Edge browser or Chrome.
          • You will receive a meeting invitation will include a link to join the meeting.
          • Separate meeting invitations will be sent for the morning and afternoon sessions of the course.
            • You will need to join the appropriate meeting at the appropriate time.
          • If you are using a microphone, please ensure that it is muted until such time as you need to ask a question.
          • The remote meeting connection will be open approximately 30 minutes before the start of the course. We encourage you to connect as early as possible in case you experience any unforeseen problems.


Please Note: This event is being conducted entirely online. All attendees will connect and attend from their computer, one connection per purchase. For details please see our FAQ

If you are unable to attend at the scheduled date and time, we make recordings available to all registrants for three business days after the event

Event Standard RateAttendees
Single Connection - Rates Performance Measurement and Benchmarking US $ 795.00
Pack of 5 connectionsUS $ 3,180.00
Pack of 10 ConnectionsUS $ 5,565.00
Pack of 20 ConnectionsUS $ 9,540.00
Call us at 303.770.8800 if you have any specific questions on the volume discounts
* all other discounts do not apply to license packs

By registering I indicate I agree with EUCI's privacy policy and understand I may receive emailed reports, articles, event invitations and other information related to products and services from EUCI and any of our business partners. I understand I may unsubscribe at any time by clicking the link included in emails.

Cancellation Policy

Your registration may be transferred to a member of your organization up to 24 hours in advance of the event. Cancellations must be received on or before June 11, 2021 in order to be refunded and will be subject to a US $195.00 processing fee per registrant. No refunds will be made after this date. Cancellations received after this date will create a credit of the tuition (less processing fee) good toward any other EUCI event. This credit will be good for six months from the cancellation date. In the event of non-attendance, all registration fees will be forfeited. In case of conference cancellation, EUCIs liability is limited to refund of the event registration fee only. For more information regarding administrative policies, such as complaints and refunds, please contact our offices at 303-770-8800

Secured By:




EUCI has been accredited as an Authorized Provider by the International Association for Continuing Education and Training (IACET).  In obtaining this accreditation, EUCI has demonstrated that it  complies with the ANSI/IACET Standard which is recognized internationally as a standard of good practice. As a result of their Authorized Provider status, EUCI is authorized to offer IACET CEUs for its programs that qualify under the ANSI/IACET Standard.

EUCI is authorized by IACET to offer 0.7 CEUs for this event.

Who Should Attend

This conference was developed for:

          • Utility executives
          • Corporate communication professionals
          • Contact center management professionals
          • Commissioners
          • Commission staff
          • Attorneys
          • Regulatory affairs managers
          • Pricing and load research managers
          • Customer representatives and organizations
          • Cost of service analysts
          • Financial analysts
          • Rate design, product development and customer strategy professionals

Requirements for Successful Completion of Program

Participants must sign in/out each day and be in attendance for the entirety of the course to be eligible for continuing education credit.

Instructional Methods

Case Studies and PowerPoint presentations

By clicking Accept or closing this message, you consent to our cookies on this device in accordance with our cookie policy unless you have disabled them. more information

By clicking Accept or closing this message, you consent to our cookies on this device in accordance with our cookie policy unless you have disabled them. You can change your cookie settings at any time but parts of our site will not function correctly without them. We use cookies during the registration process and to remember member settings.